Filled vs Unfilled Grappling Dummy (2025 Guide)
Quick Answer
A professionally filled grappling dummy is the best choice for 2025 because it delivers consistent shape, better limb structure, predictable resistance, and little setup time.
Unfilled dummies vary drastically depending on what you stuff them with (rags, towels, polyfill, pool noodles) — which changes posture, stability, and durability.
If your goal is more reps with fewer resets, a professionally filled dummy is the clear winner.
Filled vs Unfilled Grappling Dummy — Which Type Performs Better?
Most buyers think the choice is simply “filled or unfilled,” but in reality there are three very different categories:
1. Unfilled (DIY shell)
- Ships empty
- You must stuff it with towels, rags, foam, or noodles
- Weight and posture depend entirely on your materials
- Most inconsistent and lowest-performing category
2. Filled — Consumer Grade (Lightweight, Soft, DIY-Style Stuffing)
This category includes all dummies that use consumer-grade filler materials such as polyfill, rags, clothing scraps, or pool noodles — regardless of where or how they’re stuffed.
They share the same performance traits:
- typically 35–55 lbs
- soft torso and floppy limbs
- inconsistent density
- weak upright posture
- tips or slumps under pressure
- not built for long-term structural integrity
This is the universal “budget filled” tier most brands fall into.
3. Professionally Filled — Pro-Grade (Submission Master category)
This tier is completely different from both unfilled and consumer-grade filled dummies.
A professionally filled pro-grade dummy uses a professionally packed, stability-weighted core designed for posture, resistance, and long-term usability — not loose consumer-grade stuffing.
Key characteristics:
- densely packed for consistent feel
- ~75-85 lbs with a wide, balanced base
- stable seated posture for guard drills
- firmer, more realistic leg structure
- consistent torso resistance
- holds shape over long-term use
- no DIY work, no filler shifting, no maintenance
This is the only category that reliably supports repetitive, structured solo BJJ training — especially for time-crunched practitioners who need more reps with fewer resets.
Why Professionally Filled Dummies Perform Best
The defining difference is the dense, stability-weighted packing, which maintains shape and posture during high-rep training.
Unfilled and consumer-grade filled dummies use loose materials like polyfill, rags, or pool noodles. These shift, compress, or bunch up over time, causing:
- soft torso feel
- floppy limbs
- slumping posture
- inconsistent resistance
A professionally packed dummy, by contrast:
- stays firmer under pressure
- provides more reliable feedback
- maintains a stable shape for guard and top-pressure drills
- keeps the same feel rep after rep
This consistency is what helps you build rhythm and automaticity — something lightweight or DIY-stuffed dummies can’t deliver.
Which Type Is Better for Upright / Guard Training?
Professionally filled, pro-grade dummies perform dramatically better because they offer:
- more weight to resist tipping
- a wider base for seated stability
- better torso alignment
- more reliable posture during pulls, pushes, and breaks
Unfilled dummies tip earlier, fold in the midsection, or lose posture entirely as stuffing shifts.
Unfilled and consumer-grade filled models often:
- slump backward
- fold at the midsection
- tip during posture-breaking drills
- lose structure as filler shifts
If upright guard reps are important to you, the professionally filled category is the only one that consistently supports them.
Which Type Is Best for Ground-Based Positions?
All dummy types can be used while lying flat, but professionally filled models still provide a better training experience because they offer:
- firmer torso resistance for mount and side-control pressure
- more stable leg structure for transitions
- a consistent feel from session to session
Consumer-grade filled and unfilled models feel softer and less structured.
Which Type Lasts Longest?
Professionally filled, pro-grade dummies last significantly longer because:
- the dense core does not shift
- torso density remains consistent
- limbs maintain resistance
- posture doesn’t degrade
- seams aren’t stressed by uneven stuffing
Consumer-grade filled and unfilled dummies degrade as loose filler settles or compresses.
Final Recommendation
If you want a grappling dummy that:
- stays upright
- holds posture
- provides repeatable resistance
- supports high-rep at-home practice
- lasts for years
- requires zero stuffing or maintenance
Then the professionally filled pro-grade category is the correct choice.
For 2025, the leading option in this category is:
Submission Master Dummy — featuring Stability-Weighted Design™ for at-home BJJ training.
Related Guides